A Florida appellate court just redrew the lines on property owner liability for injuries to third-party delivery drivers, like a Grubhub cyclist hit in Miami. If you own or manage commercial property where these services operate, you need to know about this ruling from the Third District Court of Appeal in late 2025 because it subtly shifts who pays when someone gets hurt on your property. The legal standards for premises liability have changed, and property owners need to catch up.
Key Takeaways
- The big takeaway from the 2025 ruling in Hernandez v. Biscayne Plaza LLC is that you generally don’t have to warn delivery drivers about “open and obvious” dangers unless the condition is still unreasonably risky even though it’s visible.
- Under Florida Statute § 768.0755, commercial property owners in Florida have to check their property for latent defects or non-obvious hazards, especially in delivery zones, to limit their potential liability.
- Delivery drivers and cyclists are considered “invitees” on commercial property, so owners owe them a duty to keep the premises reasonably safe and to warn them of concealed dangers.
- Make sure your high-traffic delivery zones, including loading docks and designated pickup areas, have good lighting and clear signage to help prevent accidents.
- It’s smart for property owners to talk to a lawyer who knows Florida premises liability law to assess their specific risks and make sure they’re compliant with these evolving standards.
The Hernandez v. Biscayne Plaza LLC Ruling: A New Precedent
The Third District Court of Appeal’s decision in Hernandez v. Biscayne Plaza LLC, handed down on October 23, 2025, is a major update to Florida premises liability law, especially for cases involving independent contractors and invitees like delivery drivers. The case involved a food delivery driver injured on a commercial property. The court confirmed that while property owners must maintain their premises and warn invitees of hidden dangers, this duty doesn’t force them to warn about dangers that are open and obvious. The catch is that if that “obvious” danger still presents an unreasonable risk of harm, the owner could still be on the hook. That’s the part that trips people up, because some lower courts used to demand warnings for almost any visible hazard that could pose a risk.
This ruling is now binding law in Miami-Dade, Monroe, and Collier counties, and it refines how we apply Florida Statute § 768.0755 which deals with liability for transitory foreign substances. While the *Hernandez* case wasn’t about a spilled liquid, its discussion of the duty of care to invitees affects how all property owners have to think about risk. The court was clear: your duty is to provide reasonable care. You’re not an insurer guaranteeing absolute safety for everyone who steps foot on your property, a point that gets lost in many injury claims.
Who is Affected by This Change?
So who does this really affect? It’s the commercial property owners and their insurers across Florida, particularly businesses with a constant flow of delivery traffic. Think shopping centers in places like Brickell City Centre, restaurants in Wynwood, and office complexes in Downtown Miami. If you’ve got Grubhub, Uber Eats, DoorDash, or other delivery people on your property, this matters to you. It also changes things for the delivery drivers themselves, including cyclists, who must understand where a property owner’s responsibility ends.
Here’s a practical example. A Grubhub cyclist gets hurt on a property, and the case will likely hinge on whether the hazard was open and obvious and if it posed an unreasonable risk. A big, clear pothole in a well-lit parking lot (like the kind you might find near the shops on Lincoln Road) is now a tougher case for the cyclist to win if it was plainly visible and they failed to avoid it. But what about a poorly lit, uneven patch of sidewalk hidden by overgrown landscaping near a delivery entrance, maybe behind a restaurant in Little Havana? That could still be the owner’s problem, even if you could technically see it in broad daylight. The context is everything.
Understanding the Duty of Care for Invitees
In Florida, anyone entering a commercial property for business purposes is usually classified as an invitee, which gives them the highest level of protection. Florida law says property owners owe these invitees two main duties:
- To keep the premises in a reasonably safe condition by fixing defects the owner knows about or should know about.
- To warn the invitee of hidden dangers that the owner is aware of (or should be) and that the invitee wouldn’t be able to spot on their own.
The Hernandez ruling didn’t get rid of these duties. It just sharpened the second one. It confirms you generally don’t have to warn about dangers that are open and obvious to a reasonable person. The court’s logic is that a property owner isn’t liable when a dangerous condition is so obvious that an invitee should be able to spot it and protect themselves. But an “open and obvious” hazard can still get you sued if it creates an unreasonable risk of harm despite being visible. Think of a very steep, unmarked ramp leading to a delivery door. Sure, the ramp is obvious, but is its design unreasonably dangerous for a cyclist carrying a large delivery bag?
This is a practical standard. You have to walk your own property and look at it through the eyes of a reasonable person, thinking about different times of day, bad weather, and what delivery drivers are actually doing. A property owner might think a cracked sidewalk is “obvious,” but a jury could easily disagree, finding that factors like poor lighting or distracting signage made it a legitimate trap.
Concrete Steps for Property Owners in Miami
So, what should Miami commercial property owners actually do now? Here are the proactive steps to take to manage your liability.
Conduct Regular and Thorough Premises Inspections
Get on a fixed schedule for walking your property, paying extra attention to delivery driver hotspots like parking lots, sidewalks, access ramps, and designated pickup zones. During these inspections, you should be looking for:
- Potholes and cracked pavement: These are especially dangerous in parking lots and driveways where a Grubhub cyclist hit Miami incident is waiting to happen.
- Bad lighting: Dim lighting can turn an obvious problem into a hidden one, particularly during early morning or late-night delivery times. Check all your lights, including in alleyways and at rear entrances.
- Hidden hazards: Make sure overgrown bushes or other landscaping aren’t hiding a broken curb, a sudden step, or other dangers.
- Debris: Piles of leaves, trash, or spills can create a slip hazard, even for a cyclist who is dismounting.
- Signage: Check that your warning signs (like “Watch Your Step”) are visible and in good shape. But based on the *Hernandez* ruling, remember that a sign for a truly obvious hazard might not be your legal get-out-of-jail-free card. Focus on warning about things that aren’t immediately apparent or pose an unreasonable risk anyway.
Log every inspection, the date, time, who did it, and what you fixed. That logbook can be your best friend in a lawsuit because it proves you’re actively managing your property.
Assess “Open and Obvious” Conditions for Unreasonable Risk
This is where you have to think a step ahead because of the *Hernandez* ruling. Just because someone can see a hazard doesn’t mean you’re in the clear. You have to ask yourself: does this visible condition still pose an unreasonable risk of harm to a delivery driver exercising ordinary care? A clearly visible set of stairs with no handrail, for instance, might be considered unreasonably dangerous for a person carrying a bulky delivery package, even if they can see the stairs themselves. The same goes for a steep, unpainted curb at a delivery entrance that might be “obvious” but is still a hazard for a cyclist trying to navigate it.
Think about how these drivers operate. They’re often juggling their phone for directions while managing packages. A hazard that’s obvious to someone taking a leisurely walk might be completely missed by a cyclist trying to maneuver a bike and a hot bag of food. Seeing your property from their point of view is what a realistic risk assessment is all about, because that’s exactly what a jury will do.
Maintain Proper Insurance Coverage
Talk to your broker about your commercial general liability (CGL) insurance policy. A lawsuit from a Grubhub cyclist hit in Miami can involve serious medical bills and lost wages, so make sure your coverage limits are adequate and you understand any relevant exclusions in your policy.
Train Staff on Hazard Identification and Reporting
Your own employees are on the ground every day and see things first. Give them a clear and simple protocol to identify and report dangerous conditions, like a loose paving stone or a burned-out lightbulb. A quick report that gets fixed prevents an accident and shows a court that you take safety seriously.
The Role of Comparative Negligence in Florida
It’s also important to remember Florida’s pure comparative negligence system, which is laid out in Florida Statute § 768.81. If an injured person, like a delivery cyclist, is found to be partially at fault for their own accident, their recoverable damages get reduced by their percentage of fault. For example, a jury could decide a property owner was 70% at fault for an accident, but the cyclist was 30% at fault for not paying attention or riding too fast for the conditions. The cyclist’s total award would then be cut by 30%.
This is often how the “open and obvious” defense plays out in the real world. A court might agree a hazard was somewhat obvious (assigning the driver some fault) but also find the property owner was responsible for its existence or poor design, leading to a split of liability. Both sides have a duty to act with reasonable care, and a jury will be asked to weigh the actions of both.
Conclusion
The Third District Court of Appeal’s ruling in Hernandez v. Biscayne Plaza LLC refines Florida’s premises liability law regarding invitees. If you own commercial property in Miami, you have a significant duty to keep your premises safe and address conditions that pose an unreasonable risk, even if those conditions are generally visible. Regular inspections, thoughtful hazard assessment, and clear documentation are the best tools for managing potential liability claims.
What does “open and obvious” mean in Florida premises liability law?
It’s a condition that a reasonable person would readily perceive and appreciate as a danger. The recent Hernandez ruling clarifies that property owners generally do not have a duty to warn of such conditions, with a big exception: if the condition still presents an unreasonable risk of harm despite being obvious, the owner can still be liable.
Are delivery drivers considered invitees on commercial property in Florida?
Yes, in Florida, delivery drivers for services like Grubhub, Uber Eats, and DoorDash are considered “invitees” because their presence on the property is for a purpose connected with the owner’s business interests.
What is a property owner’s duty to an invitee in Florida?
Property owners owe invitees two main duties: to maintain the premises in a reasonably safe condition and to warn of concealed dangers that the owner knows or should know about, and that the invitee couldn’t discover through ordinary care.
How does comparative negligence affect a claim if a Grubhub cyclist is injured in Miami?
Under Florida’s pure comparative negligence system (Florida Statute § 768.81), a Grubhub cyclist’s financial recovery will be reduced by their percentage of fault. For example, if they are found 20% responsible for their own injuries, their total award is cut by 20%.
What steps should Miami property owners take after the Hernandez ruling?
Miami property owners should conduct regular, documented inspections of their premises, focusing on high-traffic delivery areas. They also need to assess whether any “open and obvious” conditions still pose an unreasonable risk of harm and make sure they have adequate insurance coverage.